LOS ANGELES - The City Council's Budget and Finance Committee moved forward on Monday with a proposal to cut $100 million to $150 million from the Los Angeles Police Department's proposed 2020-2021 budget, while community activists presented their idea for more dramatic reductions in law enforcement spending.
The committee voted to send the proposed $100 million to $150 million cuts to the full council, which will consider directing city staff to compile a report that would examine how the reductions could be made without affecting basic policing services.
But supporters of the People's Budget LA told council members Monday morning that Los Angeles needs to rethink its community policing policies.
The People's Budget LA proposal was developed by a coalition of organizations led by Black Lives Matter's Los Angeles chapter, and it seeks to have the LAPD's proposed budget cut by 90%, with the funds allocated to social services, such as mental health and housing.
LAPD's proposed operating budget for the next fiscal year is about $1.86 billion.
Five representatives from organizations in support of the People's Budget spoke to a gathering of one-third of the council, outlining results of a public survey about their proposed budget and discussing their vision for community policing.
The results from more than 24,000 respondents showed overwhelming support for funding more mental health and wellness services, housing and public health care.
David Turner of Black Lives Matter-LA said his parents struggled to get by and often argued, causing the police to show up at their home instead of family therapy workers.
"The police never helped the situation," Turner said. "Somebody always went to jail ... it was my mom or it was my dad, and because of that it broke my family apart and neither one of my parents are alive today because of the stress and because we don't invest in family therapy or restorative justice."
Turner said he's close to earning a doctorate, but there are many people who grew up in similar situations who are unable to reach the same achievements.
Actor and activist Kendrick Sampson, who founded the organization Build Power, which also goes by BLD PWR, said he wants elected officials to start re-imagining the way policing is done.
Sampson said he and his assistant were significantly injured by police officers who responded to peaceful protests about two weeks ago. "We have a really low bar with policing in terms of imagining differently for public safety, and we can imagine differently," he said.
"I don't think it's that hard, to be completely honest, but I would like to offer up, if anybody needs help, there's a whole industry here of people who imagine and get paid to imagine and ... we will offer that help up." Mayor Eric Garcetti responded Monday to the People's Budget LA on Twitter.
"I thank the People's Budget LA for your strong presentation to the City Council today," Garcetti said. "I will continue to work with my colleagues on the City Council to further invest in the needs of our communities to create lasting change."
Council President Nury Martinez, who along with four other councilmembers introduced the motion cutting up to $150 million from LAPD's budget, said the People's Budget is straight forward in its demands and that it's "not complicated."
But she also said the city is limited in its capacity on certain provisions. One of the biggest limitations is that the county, not the city, is charged with addressing public health issues, such as addressing the COVID-19 pandemic.
"I think all of us are challenged with the fact that there are certain things we can do," Martinez said.
"It's not an excuse, but everyone needs to do their fair share and make sure that they show up, not only for Angelenos but for people who live in the county of L.A. So for me, I am committed to continuing to re-imagine what my neighborhoods look like, what I want for my kid when she becomes a mom."
Councilman Mike Bonin said he would like the report on LAPD budget cuts to take into account emergency and non-emergency calls the agency receives and what drives its overtime costs, as well as recommendations that don't shelter any part of the police budget.
"I think we owe it to Los Angeles to come up with a better and smarter way of doing public safety and emergency response, and I think this motion is the first step in doing that," Bonin said.
"It's not about random slashing and cuts. It's about re-prioritizing and ... to invest in neighborhood safety, and there are ways to do that."
Akili, an organizer with BLM-LA who goes by only his last name, said he wants to see council members pledge support to reduce the police budget.
"I appreciate your sentiment, but what I'm looking for is a commitment," Akili said. "Let's move forward with a commitment, and so I'masking you now, as the (Council) President ... commit to reimagining and the defunding (of) police."
The city's general fund revenue outlook by the end of the 2019-2020 fiscal year, which ends June 30, is looking worse than it did a month ago.
According to city documents, based on May receipts, estimates from theOffice of Finance, the Department of Transportation and new information concerning sales and electricity users tax receipts show the city's revenue for2019-2020 is estimated to be $6.32 billion -- $145 million below the revised budget and $253.5 million below the proposed budget.
Councilman Paul Krekorian, the Budget Committee the chairman, said the priorities for the budget revisions due to the COVID-19 pandemic must be to pay back the funds it moved from other departments to support the city's response to the virus. He said they must also try to avoid the furloughs of city employees or reduce them as much as possible.
Krekorian said as the council considers the budget revisions for the next fiscal year, it must do so while considering any alterations will mean taking money from another department's budget.
The Budget and Finance Committee is expected to meet again next Monday and June 29 before adopting a budget by June 30. Council members have said the budget will continue to be worked on throughout the next fiscal year, which begins July 1.