'Pretty Little Liars' actor Keegan Allen pistol-whipped, robbed at gunpoint in West Hollywood

Published October 9, 2026 7:35 AM PDT

*Warning: Video above contains graphic material. Viewer discretion advised.

WEST HOLLYWOOD, Calif. – "Pretty Little Liars" actor Keegan Allen was assaulted and robbed by two armed men outside a West Hollywood luxury grocery store on Thursday night. 

The 37-year-old actor sustained a head injury during the attack and subsequently took to social media to criticize local officials over the city's crime rates.

What we know:

The violent encounter took place around 9 p.m. in the parking lot of Laurel Supply, located near Santa Monica Boulevard and Olive Drive. 

According to Allen, he was loading items into his truck when two masked men dressed in black approached him. One suspect shoved a handgun into the actor's face while the other brandished a knife, demanding his watch and bracelet.

The gunman struck Allen in the head multiple times with the pistol before the pair fled with only the watch, which early reports on the Citizen app indicated was a Rolex. 

The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department and local paramedics responded to the scene, where Allen was treated for a head laceration but was not transported to a hospital.

What they're saying:

In the immediate aftermath of the attack, a bloodied Allen shared a video and security footage to his Instagram account, explicitly stating that "West Hollywood is not safe anymore." 

He recounted the harrowing encounter to his followers, saying, "These two dudes hit me in the head and pointed a gun at me with a knife and then took off. They had masks on and took my watch. They took my watch. Dammit." 

In further comments, Allen noted he suspected he was "def concussed" and added, "Robbed at gunpoint and knifepoint by two young men that threatened to KILL me over my watch and would have! God said no tonight. My life for a watch." 

He also seemingly targeted Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass and California Governor Gavin Newsom in his posts, adding, "Will update more soon. Let’s hope all these flock cameras that (Karen Bass), (Gavin Newsom) and everyone thinks will stop crime can find these very dangerous criminals. God bless."

What we don't know:

The identities of the two suspects are unknown, and investigators have not yet released a detailed suspect description beyond the two men wearing black clothing and masks. 

It's also unclear what type of getaway vehicle was used by the suspects. 

Authorities have not confirmed whether any of West Hollywood's recently installed Flock Safety live-video cameras or license plate readers successfully captured the suspects fleeing the scene.

FOX 11 has reached out to the city of West Hollywood for comment.

The Source: This report is based on primary evidence from Keegan Allen's personal Instagram account—including his direct statements and the security footage he shared—with on-the-ground reporting by FOX 11's Gigi Graciette from the scene in West Hollywood. Details regarding the law enforcement and medical response are attributed to the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Office and paramedics via TMZ, while preliminary details about the stolen item were noted from real-time alerts on the Citizen app.

Crime and Public SafetyWest HollywoodEntertainmentInstastories